Monday, June 8, 2009

The beauty of being startled

So it turns out that most babies are born with a startle reflex (or a Moro reflex, for you experts out there): when they hear a sudden, loud noise, they extend their arms, legs, and fingers, arch their back, and draw their head back, before finally drawing their arms back into their chest. It's really kind of neat to see: something like an anemone tackling a careless tropical fish, and then retreating for a meal.

Cleo seems to be used to the occasional crash of trucks hitting potholes on Falls Road, but today it was a passage in Mozart's Eine Kleine Nachtmusik that snuck up on her while she nursed. A sudden surge in the dynamics, and that was that: baby's limbs everywhere for a wild second or two.

Thinking about it afterwards, I remembered that my dad, when he's listened to pop tracks that I've sent his way over the years (hoping for his stamp of approval on that latest Pearl Jam song or Eminem tune), has occasionally mentioned that they don't have many interesting changes in volume. It's just full intensity, for three or four minutes, where he's used to the more extended compositions of classical composers, who often (perhaps because of the length of the piece) alter moods more often, and more fully. There must be exceptions, of course, and my dad certainly didn't mean it as a rule - but it is an interesting observation, and it leads to an implicit thought experiment, which I'll simply pose to anyone who's reading: can you think of pieces that feature dramatic shifts that are sudden enough to trigger the Moro reflex?

4 comments:

  1. The first to come to mind was "Oh So Quiet" by Bjork, and then I also thought of Sigur Ros. What does it say that they're both Icelandic? Not sure...

    The lack of dynamics is getting worse with a lot of pop music, alas, as record producers flatten the peaks and valleys in an effort to make songs loader overall. So we end up startled less often, and more just exhausted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is Robin, posting as Derek for some reason.

    Any song by Mogwai (from Scotland). I have often been startled when Derek sneaks them on the hi-fi. You think you are listening to some nice ambient guitar and then suddenly the walls come crashing down. They are an instrumental band which may be why they are more into dynamics.

    Just thought of Dirty Three. Another instrumental band from Australia. I love this band, probably because they are not so startling as they do 5 minute long crescendos that just keep building upon themselves forever. You must listen to this band, Kerr, you have never heard a violinist rock out so hard. They are incredible live.

    So I'm thinking that the lack of a vocalist creates more room for dramatic dynamics. makes sense.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice suggestions, both of youse. I'd never heard of Mogwai (somehow I overlooked their work on the Miami Vice soundtrack), but was - as you predicted, Robin - jarred by the shift in We're No Here. The Bjork tune is also a great example, Ben, and points in turn to a whole genre of show tunes that I'd forgotten, but that involve roughly similar blaring horns. Now to check out Dirty Three...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Do check out Dirty Three - great stuff. Good work music. Actually, all the "post rock" bands dig on dynamics - Explosions in the Sky, godspeed you! black emperor, Toroise. Interesting that they're all instrumental bands, and not really "pop" music

    ReplyDelete